Navigating PSR: Wrexham, Birmingham City, and Middlesbrough Transfer Strategies in 2025

⚖️ Navigating PSR: Wrexham, Birmingham City & Middlesbrough’s Transfer Strategies in 2025

As the summer transfer window heats up, clubs across the EFL are not just chasing talent; they’re balancing ambition with financial compliance. The Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) are designed to prevent overspending and ensure long-term viability, shaping clubs’ operations.

With the PSR rules now a factor shaping every move, we’re spotlighting three clubs with very different strategies. Let’s dive into how three contrasting clubs, Wrexham, Birmingham City, and Middlesbrough, are managing their squads and finances whilst navigating PSR.

---

🐉 Wrexham: Ambition Meets Caution?

Wrexham enter the 2025/26 Championship season with a mix of ambition, caution, and strategic focus.

Here’s a breakdown of Wrexham’s summer 2025 transfer activity so far:

🟢 Incoming Transfers

• Lewis O’Brien – £3.08 million
• Liberato Cacace – £2.20 million
• Conor Coady – £2.02 million
• Kieffer Moore – £2.02 million
• George Thomason – £1.23 million
• Ryan Hardie – £0.73 million

🔢 Total Spent: £11.28 million

🔴 Estimated Fees Received

• Outgoing Transfers: ~£0.88 million

✅ Net Spend

£11.28m − £0.88m = £10.4 million

Total Spend: £11.28 m

Total Income: £0.88 m

Net Spend: -£10.4m

Key Signings: Conor Coady, Lewis O’Brien, Liberato Cacace, Josh Windass, Kieffer Moore

PSR Strategy: Commercial leverage and free transfers, with some investment in experienced championship-proven talent.

Wrexham’s meteoric rise — three promotions in three seasons — has been matched by savvy recruitment. Backed by Hollywood owners, they’ve splashed on players like Liberato Cacace (£2.2m), Lewis O’Brien (undisclosed but reportedly up to £5m), and, more recently, Kieffer Moore. But they’ve balanced this with free transfers (Windass, Coady) and virtually zero income from sales, relying on booming commercial revenue and global brand awareness and appeal to stay PSR compliant. 

“We don’t even know what consolidation means,” co-owner Rob McElhenney quipped on his social media account, but are Wrexham walking a tightrope between spectacle and sustainability behind the scenes?

It’s usually thought that teams coming up a division primarily focus on maintaining their newfound status (which is the norm in the Premier League above). Will they have one eye on Ipswich’s exploits from last season, though, as they managed to charge through the division for another consecutive promotion? Indeed, their fans, full of early-season optimism, will see that as a possibility, and maybe their excited Hollywood owners will too.

Others, perhaps understandably, are less certain, though. Here’s a summary of thoughts on how it might play out.

---

🎯 Primary Goals for the Season

1. Secure Championship Survival
   • As it’s their first season back in the second tier since 1981–82, the main objective is to avoid relegation and establish themselves as a stable Championship side.
2. Mid-Table Finish
   • While survival is the minimum, the club aims for a mid-table position, leveraging its strong recruitment and squad depth.
3. Cup Competitions
   • Wrexham will also compete in the FA Cup and EFL Cup, hoping to progress to later rounds to boost morale and visibility.

---

🧠 Tactical and Squad Goals

• High-Pressing Style: Manager Phil Parkinson plans to maintain a fast-paced, high-pressing approach, emphasising possession and wide play.
• Squad Depth & Rotation: With new signings like Conor Coady, Lewis O’Brien, and Kieffer Moore, the aim is to rotate effectively without compromising quality.
• Youth Integration: Pre-season showed promise from academy players, and the club wants to give them more minutes in competitive fixtures.

---

⚠️ Challenges & Expert Predictions

• EFL analysts are less optimistic and are concerned about Wrexham’s ability to compete at Championship level. Only a handful of players are seen as “Championship-ready,” and Parkinson’s record in the division is modest.
• Their opening fixtures are tough (aren’t they all?), including away games at Southampton and Millwall, and home ties against West Brom and Sheffield Wednesday.

---

🔮 Long-Term Vision

• With continued investment from owners Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney, Wrexham’s long-term goal remains Premier League promotion. However, the sensible view suggests that it’s likely to be a multi-year plan.

---

🔵 Birmingham City: Smart Spending, Strategic Sales?

After a record-breaking League One campaign, Birmingham aims for back-to-back promotions, but it’s doing it with financial discipline, and wants to be seen to be navigating PSR rules correctly

Birmingham has been clinical this window. Their marquee signing, Kyogo Furuhashi, cost £9m. Still, they offset it with sales like Romelle Donovan (£3m) and Alfie May (£1.2m). Free agents like Demarai Gray and Bright Osayi-Samuel add quality without denting the budget. Loans for Tommy Doyle and James Beadle further reduce risk. They arguably got slightly over-excited with the recent pursuit of the mercenary Chuba Akpom, but overall, their approach has been measured.

City have been very active in the 2025 summer transfer window, aiming to build a squad capable of pushing for promotion from the Championship. Here’s a full breakdown of their signings:

---

🟢 Confirmed Signings (Summer 2025)

Permanent Transfers

• Kyogo Furuhashi – Striker from Rennes (€9m / ~£7.6m)
• Taylor Gardner-Hickman – Midfielder from Bristol City (£1.5m)
• Alfons Sampsted – Right-back from FC Twente (undisclosed, ~£0.4m)
• Phil Neumann – Centre-back from Hannover 96 (Free)
• Bright Osayi-Samuel – Full-back/Winger from Fenerbahçe (Free)
• Demarai Gray – Winger from Al-Ettifaq (Free)
• Kanya Fujimoto – Midfielder from Gil Vicente (Free)

Loan Deals

• Tommy Doyle – Midfielder from Wolves
• James Beadle – Goalkeeper from Brighton
• Eiran Cashin – Centre-back from Brighto

---

🔴 Departures

• Romelle Donovan – To Brentford (£3m)
• Alfie May – To Huddersfield Town (£1.2m)
• Ayumu Yokoyama – To Genk (undisclosed)
• Emmanuel Longelo – To Motherwell (undisclosed)
• Bailey Peacock-Farrell & Emil Hansson – Loaned to Blackpool
• Grant Hanley & Myung-jae Lee – Released
• Lukas Jutkiewicz – Retired

---

💰 Financial Summary

• Total Spend: ~£3.2 million
• Total Income: ~£4.2 million
• Net Gain: ~£1 million
• PSR Strategy: Balanced books and loan market. Birmingham is threading the needle. Smart sales and free agents offset big signings like Kyogo. Loans add depth without denting the budget. After a record-breaking League One season, they’re chasing promotion with discipline.

Birmingham City’s goals for the 2025/26 Championship season are ambitious and reflect their rapid rise and strong backing. Here’s a summary of their objectives:

---

🎯 Primary Goals

1. Push for Promotion to the Premier League
   • Investor Tom Brady has publicly stated that the club’s ambition is to build on last season’s League One title and aim for promotion.
   • He emphasised maintaining high standards and competitive stamina, acknowledging the tougher competition in the Championship.
2. Play-Off Qualification
   • Sky Sports pundit David Prutton predicts Birmingham will launch a serious play-off push, describing them as “a team in a hurry” with aggressive recruitment and Premier League aspirations.

---

🧠 Strategic Focus

• Squad Integration: With 10+ new signings, including Kyogo Furuhashi and Tommy Doyle, the club is focused on quickly integrating players into manager Chris Davies’ tactical system.
• Learning from Past Mistakes: After a failed experiment with Wayne Rooney in 2023/24, the club is now more measured in its approach, balancing ambition with realism.

---

🏆 Cup Competitions

• Birmingham will also look to make a mark and compete well in the cup competitions. They expect to progress beyond the early rounds and showcase their squad depth.

---

💬 Tom Brady’s Message

“We set a new standard last season. The games are harder now, the players are better, and we need to step up in every area. The goal is to build on what we did and keep pushing forward.”

Blues fans know that lofty ambitions can come at a price if things don’t go well; they’re probably still having nightmares over recent “adventures” with high-profile managers, which perhaps ultimately led to the team’s fall into League 1. They’ll keep their fingers crossed for a much better outcome this time. Here’s a summary of the potential risks and pitfalls.

🔵 Birmingham City – Implications of High Ambition

1. Squad Pressure & Expectations

• Players are under pressure to deliver quickly, especially new signings like Kyogo Furuhashi and Tommy Doyle.
• Manager Chris Davies must integrate talent rapidly and maintain consistency.

2. Financial Commitment

• Promotion ambitions often mean higher spending on wages, bonuses, and infrastructure.
• The club may stretch its budget to stay competitive, especially if results falter.

3. Fan & Media Scrutiny

• With Tom Brady’s involvement and public statements, expectations are sky-high.
• Any dip in form could lead to intense media and fan criticism.

4. Risk of Disruption

• If promotion isn’t achieved, managerial changes or squad overhauls could occur.
• Long-term plans may be re-evaluated if short-term goals aren’t met.

---

🔴 Middlesbrough: Selling to Rebuild

Total Spend: £0m
The Spending is hard to quantify as deals for the 3 players signed so far have been undisclosed. It is likely balanced out by the net income from the Coburn sale.
Total Income: £5m
Net Profit: £5m
Key Departures: Josh Coburn (£5m to Millwall)
Key Signings: Alfie Jones, Abdoulaye Kante, Callum Brittain (all undisclosed)
PSR Strategy: Reset and reinvest

Middlesbrough’s approach is conservative but strategic. After a disappointing 10th-place finish last time out, and a managerial change (Rob Edwards in, Carrick out), they’ve sold Josh Coburn for a tidy £5m. Their incomings are low-cost or undisclosed, suggesting a focus on rebuilding without breaching PSR limits.

They are reportedly looking at further signings to boost the squad; this may depend, though, on the successful sale of existing assets such as Hayden Hackney and Rav van Den Berg, both of whom are attracting bids from elsewhere.

With no significant outlays, Boro are banking on bright recruitment and internal development to climb back into playoff contention.

All of these factors make it hard to predict where Boro might finish this season

Middlesbrough FC’s 2025/26 Championship season goals reflect a transitional phase under new head coach Rob Edwards, focusing on rebuilding and steady progress. Here’s a breakdown of their objectives and strategic direction:

---

🎯 Primary Goals

1. Top-Half Finish

• Middlesbrough’s aim is for a top-half position, hoping to push toward the play-off places if momentum builds.
• The club is not publicly targeting automatic promotion, but a play-off run is seen as a realistic stretch goal.

2. Squad Rebuild Under Rob Edwards

• With Michael Carrick departing, Rob Edwards has been brought in on a three-year contract to reshape the team and implement a more dynamic style of play.
• The club has invested in younger talent and Championship-proven players, signalling a medium-term rebuild.

---

🧠 Strategic Focus

• Defensive Solidity: Signings like Callum Brittain and Alfie Jones aim to shore up the back line.
• Youth Integration: Players like Archie Baptiste and Jayden Carbon suggest focusing on developing future starters.
• Squad Depth: With several players returning from loan and others released, the club is streamlining its squad for tactical flexibility.

---

🏆 Cup Competitions

• Boro will, of course, compete in the FA Cup and EFL Cup, with the first Carabao Cup fixture against Doncaster Rovers coming soon.
• Cup runs are more likely to be seen as opportunities for squad rotation and youth development than for success.

---

🔮 Long-Term Vision

• The club is celebrating its 150th season, and Steve Gibson’s leadership is focused on building a sustainable path back to the Premier League.
• The emphasis is on stability, tactical evolution, and financial prudence.
• Middlesbrough FC’s long-term goals reflect a commitment to sustainable growth, community engagement, and returning to top-flight football through  a measured, strategic progress rather than short-term spending sprees.

---

Here’s what experts are predicting for Middlesbrough FC in the 2025/26 Championship season:

---

📉 General Outlook

• Most pundits expect a mid-table finish, with predictions ranging from 13th to 14th place.
• The club is seen as being in transition following Michael Carrick’s departure and Rob Edwards’s appointment as head coach.

---

🧠 Managerial Concerns

• Rob Edwards is considered a talented coach but comes with baggage from a demanding spell at Luton Town.
• Analysts worry about his confidence and ability to bounce back, especially with a challenging fixture list to start the season.

---

🔑 Key Players

• Finn Azaz is highlighted as a potential star, having contributed 23 goals and assists last season.
• Hayden Hackney remains a crucial figure, though his future is uncertain after rejecting a move to Ipswich.

---

⚠️ Challenges

• A quiet transfer window and a lack of squad depth are major concerns
• The team has lost experienced players like Jonny Howson and Josh Coburn, and hasn’t reinvested heavily as yet

---

🧭 Expert Prediction Summary

📊 Comparative Snapshot

Club Name	Financial Approach	Squad Investment	Youth Development	Risk Level	Long-Term Sustainability Focus
Wrexham AFC	Measured spending with controlled net spend (£10.4m)	Focused on Championship readiness with strategic signings	Gradual integration of academy players	Moderate	Build infrastructure and squad depth for future growth
Birmingham City	Aggressive investment (£3.2m spend, £4.2m income)	High-profile signings and loans to push for promotion	Limited focus; priority on experienced players	High	Promotion-driven strategy with investor backing
Middlesbrough FC	Financial prudence with net profit (£5m)	Minimal new signings; reliance on loan returns	Strong emphasis on academy integration	Low	Strategic rebuild with focus on youth and financial health

🧠 Final Thoughts

Navigating PSR rules forces clubs to be more creative, cautious, and calculated. Wrexham is pushing boundaries with commercial muscle, Birmingham is threading the needle with smart deals, and Middlesbrough is playing the long game. Whether it’s Wrexham’s spectacle, Birmingham’s balance, or Boro’s rebuild, each path reflects a unique blend of identity and ambition.

One thing is for sure: PSR and sound financial management are much more prominent in English football these days. Fans are starting to realise that what was once the “common man’s game” is now much more focused on ensuring that clubs are run responsibly as businesses.

Some find it hard to take and/or understand, as the regulations are seen as something that stifles the ambition of clubs trying to make it to the big league, favouring those already in those lofty positions. While this may or may not be true, financial regulations have always existed; recently, they’ve been enforced more strictly.

Many see it as ruining the game, and maybe it is for those who have followed their teams for decades. Arguably, though, more regulation has to be seen as a good thing if we’re going to avoid more of what we see happening at Morecambe FC currently. Time will tell ….

—

Want More?
Get in touch with your thoughts or let us know which club you want us to profile next!